A good story isn't always yours to tell
Nonprofit communications often depends on telling other people's stories. The challenge is knowing what you're entitled to share, what belongs to the person sharing it, and when the most compelling version isn't the most responsible one.
A story can be accurate and still be exploitative.
That distinction matters in organizations whose work involves people experiencing hardship. There is no shortage of compelling stories to tell, and there is often a genuine reason to tell them. Stories help donors understand the impact of their contributions, help communities recognize a need, and give people a reason to care about work they might otherwise never see.
But the fact that a story serves an organization’s mission doesn’t automatically make it ours to tell.
A person is not an illustration of your mission.
The easiest way to make an impact story compelling is to center the hardship. The more difficult the circumstances, the more emotionally persuasive the story can become.
It’s also where things can go wrong.
When someone’s experience becomes a vehicle for demonstrating an organization’s value, the person can disappear behind the problem they’re being used to illustrate. A family becomes an example of food insecurity. A client becomes a story about homelessness. Their circumstances become the most important thing about them, because those are the details most likely to move an audience.
I try to approach storytelling with a different question: would this person recognize themselves in the way we’re representing them?
That means paying attention to more than factual accuracy. It means considering which details are necessary, which are gratuitous, and whether the story gives someone room to be a whole person rather than a collection of difficult circumstances.
Consent is the beginning, not the finish line.
Getting permission to share someone’s story is essential. But consent alone doesn’t answer every editorial question.
Someone can agree to participate without knowing exactly how a photograph, quote, or personal detail might be used across different platforms. They may be comfortable sharing one part of their experience and not another. And even when permission is clear, that doesn’t mean every detail needs to make it into the final piece.
The responsibility still belongs to the person publishing the story.
This is where editorial judgment matters. Sometimes the most emotional detail is also the least necessary. Sometimes a broader description communicates the impact just as effectively without exposing someone’s personal circumstances. The goal isn’t to extract as much as possible from someone’s experience. It’s to share enough to help an audience understand.
Dignity makes for better storytelling.
There is a tendency to think that responsible storytelling requires sacrificing emotional impact. I don’t think that’s true.
People are more interesting than their hardships. Their decisions, relationships, goals, humor, and perspectives often make for a much more meaningful story than a description of what went wrong.
For nonprofit communications, this also changes how impact is presented. Instead of positioning an organization as the hero who rescued someone, the story can show what support made possible while keeping the individual at the center of their own experience.
That distinction matters. The organization provided a service. The person lived the experience.
The strongest story isn’t always the one with the most detail.
Communications professionals spend a lot of time thinking about what to include: the strongest quote, the most compelling photograph, the detail that will make someone stop scrolling. Ethical storytelling requires spending just as much time thinking about what to leave out.
A story doesn’t become less meaningful because it protects someone’s privacy. And an organization doesn’t need to share every difficult detail to demonstrate that its work matters.
The responsibility of telling someone else’s story is not just to make people care. It’s to make sure the person whose story we’re telling is treated with care, too.
Written by Lindsay Mauss. If this was useful, or you disagree with it, say so.